Unity Church pastor Gillette established mission church in Latrobe

Article courtesy of the Latrobe Bulletin. See original article here.

Another pastor who made a profound impact on the Latrobe area community was the Rev. Noah Halleck Gillette, who occupied the pulpit at Unity Presbyterian Church during the mid-1800s.

“The really neat part about (Gillette’s) story is, first of all, how he ended up here in the first place because it was by accident,” said Mary Lou Townsend, executive director of the Latrobe Area Historical Society. “His horse stumbled and fell and broke its leg. (Gillette) was on his way to Ohio and stayed in the area while the leg healed.

“It wasn’t in Unity Township, but he was at another congregation first in the area.”

The most profound aspect of Gillette’s arrival in 1849, however, is that “Latrobe was laid out in lots two years later,” according to Townsend.

As more and more residents were leaving Unity Township and moving into town, Gillette would come in from Unity and hold services for the Presbyterians who settled in Latrobe.

“In 1857, he established a mission church in town, and the building still stands,” Townsend said. “It was built in 1857, and it’s across from the Mozart (Hall). Now it has a big red brick facade that says IOOF (Independent Order of Odd Fellows) for the Odd Fellows.”

The building is located at 345 Main St. in downtown Latrobe. An adjacent parking lot provides a glimpse into the building’s past.

“There’s a parking lot beside it, and if you walk into that parking lot, you can see the yellow bricks and the shape of the church windows and everything.”

Gillette ministered there until his death in 1869. He was 69 years old.

“Just around the time he died, he had encouraged this mission to apply to become their own congregation, and they did in 1869, and that’s Latrobe Presbyterian Church,” Townsend said. “So he was the one responsible for the church that’s still here now.”

And according to historical accounts, Gillette had a rather unique preaching style.

“If the service had started and somebody came in late, he just stopped and waited until that person was seated, so it became very obvious,” Townsend said. “He was also fussy about the music when (the congregation) was singing.”

Gillette also played an important role in reuniting Unity parishioners after an 1839 rift created the “Old School” and “New School” split in the Presbyterian denomination.

“Peter Hassinger was the minister when that split occurred,” Townsend said, “but it was Rev. Gillette who managed to bring the two sides together again.”

“‘Old School’ was conservative – keep things the way they’ve been – and the ‘New School’ was more progressive,” said Townsend. “There were a number of issues. I can’t get into the theology of it, but some of it had to do with the style of preaching, the hierarchy of the church, and one of the issues was slavery.”

The 1839 split lasted at least a decade, Townsend said, although the rift’s exact ending is unknown.

Hassinger was at the pulpit from 1839-1844, while Gillette served the church from 1849-1868.

“Under (Gillette’s) administration, the division was healed,” according to information from the Unity Cemetery and Chapel history book, the “New School” church “was torn down and the congregation was reunited.”

Gillette’s headstone is no longer at his gravesite un Unity Cemetery, but his wife’s is, however it has fallen over, Townsend said.

“Even his wife, I don’t know where the headstone is,” Townsend noted. “I found a picture on findagrave.com, and it shows the headstone leaning back against the base, but I’ve never been able to find it. It may be face down.”

Those interested in the history or attending upcoming events can learn more, including dates, times and locations, on the Unity Cemetery and Chapel 250th anniversary website, unitycemeterychapel.org.

This is the 11th piece of a biweekly series that will run through the end of the year honoring, celebrating and telling the stories from Unity Cemetery’s 250th anniversary, and Unity Chapel’s 150th anniversary. From marriages to funerals, many of our local families’ lives are touched by the history of the cemetery and chapel. It is one of few institutions in the area older than the nation itself. We look forward to bringing these stories into your homes every other Saturday for the rest of the year, and hope you look forward to reminiscing on some stories that maybe you once knew, as well as those you may not know.